Some companies are proud that nobody leaves. Tenure is long, talent churn is low, and people talk about the place with real warmth. They mean it, because it’s true, and this is an achievement of which leadership can be proud.
But with the arrival of PE backing, the way this element of a company’s culture was built gets stress-tested. Hard. (For more on this, read how ownership changes test which habits are worth keeping.)
Retention vs. Resilience
The way a company holds on to its people is often the way it has left them untested. One way is what I call (over) protectionism. Leaders tend to absorb an imbalanced level of the overall pressure so their teams don’t have to. Low targets are set. Criteria for escalations and leadership involvement are low (or lacking). Leaders carry delivery themselves, or manage so closely that nobody holds a decision long enough to get it wrong. The intent is kind. The talent retention is strong, and the results speak for themselves.
Why being kind can be cruel
New ownership brings new and more rigorous structure. Clearer targets, tighter reporting, a pace the business has never run at. Everyone is expected to measure up.
And for many people working in this new normal, it might mean quite a few “firsts”:
The first time having truly ambitious targets, that are;
real, and to which they will be held to account, and;
for which failure to achieve said targets has real consequences
The usual response is to treat this as a morale problem. Leaders reassure, soften the message and take on more of the load. That is the original behaviour applied harder, at the moment it does the most damage.
The issue is that the team that is under this new pressure is a team that has never had smaller doses of stress. Like a body that has never been exposed to anything to which it has to create antibodies, it has no built-up and built-in tolerance when the real thing arrives.
In short, what we as leaders do when we “step in” is to weaken our team in a small and meaningful way. Done thousands of times over years, this weakens them immeasurably, and then we enter a new and fast-paced world of rapid scaling.
Resilience cannot be installed in a single quarter. It is built by giving people real accountability in small, survivable amounts, and the time to start is before the change lands, not during it.
The question to ask before you step in
The next time you feel the pull to step in, ask yourself one thing. Am I intervening because, if I don’t, someone will be damaged? Or because it is uncomfortable for me to watch them feel a pain that would not harm them, but would teach them?
It is the question a parent faces when helping a child become self-sufficient. You definitely intervene before they run into traffic. You don’t necessarily step in before the scraped knee. Fear and intentionality can look identical from the outside, so the check has to be an honest one. ( By the way, when the discomfort is about a conversation you would rather not have, see why technically brilliant leaders avoid difficult performance conversations, and what helps shift it.)
I am not suggesting we leave our teams to struggle. The consequences of failure are real. But so is the cost of the failure we are building towards. We may be steering ourselves into a much bigger failure further down the road, in the name of avoiding a smaller one today.
As with most questions in senior leadership, this one has no clean or fully reassuring answer. It still needs answering honestly, every time.
The harder truth is that this test is not on the team. It is on us. PE ownership did not create the question of whether we act from fear or from intention. It made it impossible to avoid.
Retention shows how well we hold our people. It says nothing about how well they can carry a load.
